Who can tell: "I was there."
The international conference "Tolkien and philosophy", organized by 'Philosophical Studies Institute Thomistic of Modena and by' Associazione Romana Studi Tolkien was an important event, successful and, above all, enjoyable. A day of work, a weekend side by side with Verlyn Flieger, Tom Shippey and Christopher Garbowski, not to mention "our" Andrea Monda, Wu Ming 4 and Franco Manni. Nine hours (number Tolkien par excellence!) For deep reflection, you fly as if they were chatting with friends. And even though May 22 was the first Saturday of sunshine after weeks of rain, a crowd of nearly 180 people concerned preferred to withdraw into a conference room, look to return to Middle-earth from different points of view.
The organization had been treated especially Thomistic Institute (which was playing at home), but we ARST as we have our active support, and we hope we have helped to make the whole day was a success .
After the ritual opening address of President of the Thomistic and ARST, started the first long-awaited action: Tom Shippey, probably the greatest expert in the world the work of Tolkien, and Franco Manni magazine Endòre have entered into a friendly but intense debate about "Tolkien between philosophy and philology." Manni, of course, the proponent of the philosophy, gave a hard time to Shippey, a philologist, but in our opinion in the dispute has brought the palm of a well-deserved victory.
Garbowski was followed by Christopher, and dense with an important speech on "Philosophy and Tolkien's theology of death." After participating in a group of two-year study on "Death and Immortality in Tolkien" (which resulted in volume The Sickle broken ) we had to be alert and interested, and in fact we found inspiration and ideas worthy of note. Garbowski remarkable passage in which he recalled "the way to immortality Hobbit: do children."
After a brief stop for lunch (in short hobbit sense) there has been what many people consider the time highlight of the day: the debate between Andrew Monda and on Wu Ming 4 "Tolkien's Catholic thinker?". I finally passed the surprise gave a face to one of the Wu Ming (no, not publish her picture, because it is coming move, you need to know that some have likened in appearance to Caravaggio), we were very impressed with the preparation and passion that debating both have shown, that Andrea was regarded by some viewers as his best presentation ever, Wu Ming 4 was, especially for the many who had never heard a real revelation. Just a shame that the two "litigants" and then not have fought so much, and often instead of being in agreement on many points. We who were there, and we followed the preparation of the meeting, but we can confirm that there was no combine : the meeting is valid (result: essentially a tie).
The last surgery was really amazing for all those (many) who had never had the opportunity to hear the voice of Verlyn Flieger. To transmit a part of the surprise and emotion, do not hesitate to steal the words of a professional speech, Wu Ming 4 :
"I have a feeling that I was a bit 'in love with a woman of seventy-seven years by the name by Verlyn Flieger. A small, skinny woman (to the point compares himself to Gollum), with a penetrating gaze and a voice like few images that will be that of Galadriel. When she read the verses in Quenya and Entish (apologizing for the pronunciation), in absolute silence of the room, I had the shakes. And when he spoke of Tolkien's theory of language, with a clear action, no flaws, the exact number of words to say the exact number of things and not a comma, too, gave me a sense of perfection, a height at the expense of small stature. "
the evening, members Organizers had the privilege of living a purely convivial evening with renowned speakers. And here's that name pronounced with reverence, reading, studying and translating Tolkien's criticism of their essays, have become real faces and smiling. Professor Shippey, Leeds supporter and fan of football, champing at the bit to watch the Champions League final (rooting, sportsmanship, for the Italian team). Professors Garbowski and Flieger (along with his friendly companion) were surrounded by confusion of merry table, and between m steaming pizza, beer, laughter and occasional problems of translation, have shown once again to be great connoisseurs of culture hobbit, without any apparent effort by supporting such an enterprise.